Photoelectric smoke alarms react best to the visible smoke from smouldering fires, and ionisation alarms react best to the invisible particles from fast flaming fires. The South Australian Metropolitan Fire Service (MFS) says research shows photoelectric alarms give the best detection across a range of fires, and it recommends photoelectric alarms, hardwired and interconnected, for every home.
What’s the difference between photoelectric and ionisation smoke alarms?
Both types are covered by the same Australian Standard, AS 3786, whose title describes smoke alarms “using scattered light, transmitted light or ionization”. They sense smoke in different ways, and the MFS smoke alarms fact sheet sums up the difference.
Photoelectric alarms use light to sense smoke. They detect larger smoke particles, the visible products of combustion, and are most effective with smouldering fires. The MFS says they are suitable near kitchens and in areas with combustion heaters or open fires.
Ionisation alarms detect small diameter smoke particles, the invisible products of combustion, and are most effective with flaming fires. They contain a minute particle of radioactive material. The MFS says they are not suitable for locations affected by cooking, combustion heating appliances or open fires.
Early warning of smoke is the point of any alarm. The MFS notes that most fire related deaths result from breathing toxic fire gases rather than from direct contact with flame or heat.
Which smoke alarm do SA fire services recommend?
Photoelectric. The MFS position is clear.
- “Research indicates that photo-electric alarms provide the best detection across a range of fires.”
- The best protection is photoelectric alarms that are hardwired to the 240 V supply and interconnected, to give the earliest warning possible.
- Homes that already have ionisation alarms should add interconnected photoelectric alarms, and replace the ionisation alarms with photoelectric ones when they reach 10 years of age.
- For caravans and motorhomes, the MFS recommends a photoelectric alarm with a hush button (MFS recreational vehicles fact sheet).
Are ionisation smoke alarms still legal in South Australia?
Yes. South Australian law requires smoke alarms that comply with AS 3786, of the right power type for the home’s build date and sale history. It doesn’t specify photoelectric or ionisation (MFS smoke alarm legislation).
Queensland is different. There, every home must have interconnected photoelectric alarms by 1 January 2027, and alarms must not contain an ionisation sensor (Queensland Government). That rule doesn’t apply in SA.
How can you tell which type of smoke alarm you have?
Take the alarm off its base, or look closely at the label.
- A black and yellow radiation symbol on the casing means it’s an ionisation alarm (MFS).
- The label or packaging names the type. The MFS also uses the term “photo-optical” for photoelectric alarms.
- The manufacture or replace by date tells you how long it has left. Every smoke alarm, of either type, should be replaced at least every 10 years.
If your alarms are ionisation and near the end of their life, that’s the natural time to switch. Our guide to interconnected smoke alarms in SA explains the wiring options.
Where should photoelectric alarms go?
Whichever type you choose, position decides how quickly it senses smoke. The MFS fact sheet recommends these locations.
- In a hallway leading to bedrooms, an alarm at the end closest to the living area.
- If bedrooms open straight off the living area, an alarm outside each bedroom, 900 mm from the doorway.
- If you sleep with bedroom doors closed, extra alarms inside the bedrooms, interconnected with the rest.
- On a two storey home, alarms on each level, interconnected.
- On a sloping ceiling, between 500 mm and 1,500 mm down the slope from the apex.
Keep alarms out of dead air spaces in corners, away from bathrooms and laundries where steam can set them off, and away from constant draughts. The MFS doesn’t recommend mounting them on side walls.
For residents who are deaf or hard of hearing, the MFS notes that alarms with strobe lights and vibrating pads are available. This matters in supported living, and our page on SDA and NDIS fire safety covers it in more detail.
How do you get rid of old ionisation alarms?
In South Australia you can put up to two domestic ionisation alarms in household waste in any 7 day period. Old photoelectric alarms can go out with normal rubbish. Either way, take any removable batteries out first and drop them at a battery recycling point (MFS smoke alarm disposal).
Hardwired alarms must be removed and replaced by a licensed electrician. VD Fire & Electrical supplies and fits photoelectric smoke alarms across Adelaide, with hardwired work done by our licensed electrical contractor, and annual smoke alarm testing starts from $89 + GST per property.